Call me old fashion, but I can not stand some of the new takes on old Christmas carols and hymns. I like Bing Crosby and the Andrews Sister’s version of “Santa Claus is Comin’ To Town”. They play it in “A Christmas Story” during one of the kitchen scenes. The Mormon Tabernacle choir’s “Silent Night” brings tears to my eyes. Stevie Nick’s version doesn’t.
I like Dean Martin and “Baby It’s Cold Outside”…..without Martina McBride singing along. Just because Natale Cole did it with her father doesn’t mean you can do a better job. Stick to country Martina. Michael Buble has a fantastic voice. He’s got a very ‘broadway’ sound. Was he in the Drama Club in high school? I bet he was. But I don’t care for his version of this song either. Rod Stewart and Dolly Parton’s take is about all I’ll tolerate as far as updating this popular classic. Dolly makes you picture the whole scenario in your head as she “talks” about needing to leave but surrenders to Rod’s advances.
Burl Ives is a Christmas icon. Funny that he was Jewish. “Holly Jolly Christmas” from Rudolph is classic! As is “Frosty The Snowman” by Jimmy Durante. I like them!
Bing Crosby “White Christmas” is epic. His whole album is.
My 24 year old also likes the older versions as well. It must be that Christmas as gotten SO commercialized that these older versions are the only elements that keep the holiday pure.
I saw a neon pink Christmas tree at Hobby Lobby in October. NEON PINK! Are you kidding me? That’s really keeping things in the Christmas spirit. I’m surprised it wasn’t aluminum.
I’ve heard SO many versions of “Let It Snow” I’ve decided I don’t like it anymore.
You can not have “Sleigh Ride” without the horses neighing at the end as in Arthur Fiedlers version. Trumpet interpretations aren’t the same.
Trans Siberian Orchestra has some awesome musicians and players. But an electric guitar in “Carol of the Bells”? Sort of kills the meaning. Bells, guitar, bells, guitar…..Mmm, no, not working. They did do “Canon in D” wonderfully! I like Manheim Steamroller. They’ve got some alternative twists on some classics that I actually don’t mind. “Auld Lang Syne” is done beautifully.
I heard a rendition of “Silent Night” today that wasn’t very pretty. The performer hung onto a note at the end for….no joke….10 seconds. That may not seem like a long time, but for a song, it is. Butchered it, totally butchered it.
Bruce Springsteen murdered “Santa Claus is Coming to Town” with his live version.
You have every performers own Christmas and holiday song. Elton John, Paul McCartney, John Lennon, The Waitresses (love their song “Christmas Wrapping”, “I Want A Hippopotamus For Christmas (seems to be a big hit in my area for reason-I can’t stand it!), Dominic the Christmas Donkey (another hit in my area-local radio station can’t seem to play it enough *gag*), and others are some what tolerable. Faith Hill has one called “A Child Changes Everything” which is very pretty. Funny, I haven’t heard it yet this year. “All I Want For Christmas Is You” is nice if it’s not sung in my face by Mariah Carey.
There are songs I don’t even hear on the radio. “I Saw Three Ships” and “Away In The Manger” are ones I only have on vinyl.
If you’re going to update, do it right.
Merry Christmas friends! Hope the season brings warmth and happiness! And no heartburn.













